[00:00:02]
[1. CALL TO ORDER – 5:30 PM]
UH, GOOD EVENING.TODAY IS NOVEMBER 4TH AT FIVE 30.
THIS IS THE HISTORICAL LANDMARK COMMISSION MEETING, UH, CALLING TO ORDER.
DOES ANY OF THE COMMISSIONERS HAVE ANY CONFLICTS ON THE TWO ITEMS TODAY ON THE AGENDA? NOPE.
UM, PUBLIC COMMENTS SOUND BELIEVE ANYBODY SIGNED UP? 'CAUSE THERE'S PRIESTS NOBODY HERE TODAY EXCEPT FOR MR. ADAMS
[4. CONSENT AGENDA: All items listed below within the Consent Agenda are considered routine by the Historic Landmark Commission and may be enacted with one motion. There will be no separate discussion of items unless a Commission Member or citizen so requests, in which event the item may be moved to the general order of business and considered in its normal sequence.]
AGENDA.UH, FIRST ITEM 2 0 2 5 5 6 2 IS CONSIDERED APPROVAL OF MINUTES FOR THE HISTORICAL LANDMARK COMMISSION MEETING ON OCTOBER 7TH, 2005.
UM, IF ANYBODY HAS ANY QUESTIONS OR LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION ON THE MINUTES, A MOVE THAT WE ACCEPT THE MINUTES IS RIGHT.
MAY I HAVE, UH, FIRST BY COMMISSIONER GRAVES, THE SECOND BY COMMISSIONER WRIGHT.
LOOK, I DON'T KNOW THE RESULTS ARE.
I DID SIGN IN AND NOTHING HAPPENED.
I THINK YOU HAVE TO SELECT YOUR NAME FIRST AND THEN SIGN IN.
OKAY, THE MINUTES, UM, ARE APPROVED NOW TO THE REGULAR
[A. HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING AND CONSIDER A REQUEST FOR A DEMOLITION PERMIT FOR THE STRUCTURE(S) LOCATED AT 604 OGRADY ST.]
AGENDA.OPEN UP THE PUBLIC HEARING AT 5 33 FOR ACTION.
IT IS TO CONSIDER A REQUEST OF DEMOLITION PERMIT FOR A STRUCTURE LOCATED AT 6 0 4 OH GRADY STREET.
CAN I GET THIS ISN'T THE RIGHT AGENDA THAT I HAVE.
I HAVE THE PLANNING AND ZONING ONE.
THIS IS, THIS IS WHAT'S ON THE AGENDA FOR THE MOST PART THOUGH.
THESE TWO ITEMS. OKAY, GO FOR IT.
I WAS LIKE, THAT'S NONE OF THOSE NUMBERS YOU'RE SAYING ARE ON THAT PAPER.
UH, SO THIS ITEM IS, UM, UH, UH, AS THE CHAIRWOMAN SAID, THIS IS FOR A DEMOLITION AT 6 0 4 OH GRADY STREET.
UM, THE APPLICANT IS M-R-M-R-C-L FLATIRON, LLC.
THEY'RE THE PROPERTY OWNER, UH, AND THEY'RE LOOKING TO DEMOLISH A SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE AND AN ACCESSORY STRUCTURE.
UH, THIS IS LOCATED OUTSIDE OF THE HISTORIC DISTRICT, BUT IT IS OLDER THAN 50 YEARS OLD, WHICH IS WHY WE'RE HERE TONIGHT.
UH, THIS IS A SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE AND A SHED.
IT WAS CONSTRUCTED IN 1963, UM, 1,142 SQUARE FEET APPROXIMATELY, AND AS YOU CAN SEE, APPEARS TO BE IN POOR CONDITION.
WE DID CONDUCT A SITE VISIT, AND THESE ARE SOME PHOTOS FROM THAT VISIT WHERE YOU CAN SEE THE EXTERIOR AND SOME OF THE FOUNDATION DAMAGE.
AND THIS IS A PHOTO OF THE ACCESSORY SHED THAT THEY ARE PROPOSING TO DEMOLISH AS WELL.
THERE WERE 84 NOTIFICATIONS MAILED TO PROPERTIES WITHIN 500 FEET.
UH, ANNA, IT WAS NOTICED IN THE BERNIE STAR.
13 RESPONSES WERE RECEIVED IN FAVOR OF DEMOLITION OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING, UH, FOR, FOR THIS PUBLIC HEARING.
UH, ADDITIONALLY, I DID RECEIVE ONE IN THE MAIL IT THIS AFTERNOON, WHICH WAS ALSO IN FAVOR.
THIS PROPERTY IS NOT A HISTORIC LANDMARK, UM, AND DOES NOT HAVE ANY ARCHITECTURAL, CULTURAL OR EDUCATIONAL VALUE, UM, THAT STAFF COULD IDENTIFY.
AND I AM OPEN TO ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU MIGHT HAVE.
AND I, I TOURED THE HOME, UM, WITH FRANKIE AND I MEAN, I CAN SEE IN THE VIDEOS.
I MEAN, THE PICTURES, UH, THE HOUSE HAS BEEN ON, ADDED ON SEVERAL TIMES, AND KIND OF THE JOINTS WHERE THEY WERE ALL ADDED ARE CLEARLY MALFUNCTIONING.
THEY'RE NOT STAYING TOGETHER VERY WELL.
UM, IT IS PEER AND BEAM AND YOU CAN DEFINITELY SEE FOUNDATION ISSUES.
UM, AS YOU'RE WALKING AROUND THE HOUSE.
SHE POINTED OUT ONE OF THE PICTURES.
YOU SEE IT IN THE CORNER, BUT THERE'S REALLY NOTHING WORTH SAVING THAT WAS VISIBLE WHEN WE VISITED THE SITE.
NO ONE HAS ANY MORE COST QUESTIONS.
I'LL CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING AND WE CAN VOTE IF ANYBODY HAS A MOTION.
[00:05:05]
WE HAVE TO READ IT CHAIR.I MAKE A MOTION THAT THE HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION ACCEPT THE FINDINGS AND APPROVE A DEMOLITION PERMIT REQUEST FOR STRUCTURE LOCATED AT 6 0 4 OH BRADY STREET, INCLUDING THE ACCESSORY DWELLING.
I HAVE A MOTION BY COMMISSIONER WRIGHT AND A SECOND BY COMMISSIONER MADAM.
AND THE MOTION PASSED, UH, FOR DEMO AT 6 0 4 OH OH GRADY.
[B. HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING AND CONSIDER A REQUEST FOR A DEMOLITION PERMIT FOR THE STRUCTURE(S) LOCATED AT 144 GARDEN ST.]
UH, ACTION ITEM 2 0 2 5 5 6 5.I'M OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONSIDER A REQUEST OF A DEMOLITION PERMIT AS STRUCTURE LOCATED AT 1 44 GARDEN STREET.
UM, AS YOU SAID, THIS IS FOR A DEMOLITION.
UH, THIS PROPERTY, UM, IS OWNED BY STACEY AND RUSSELL KNOLL.
IT IS REPRESENTED BY BEN ADAMS, WHO IS HERE TONIGHT.
UM, THEIR REQUEST IS TO DEMOLISH THE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE.
THIS PROPERTY IS LOCATED OUTSIDE OF THE HISTORIC DISTRICT, BUT IT IS OLDER THAN 50 YEARS, WHICH IS WHY IT IS BEFORE YOU TONIGHT.
THIS IS A SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE AND THERE ARE TWO SHEDS ON SITE.
UM, IT WAS CONSTRUCTED IN 1956.
IT IS 1,233 SQUARE FEET APPROXIMATELY PER CAD.
UM, THERE DOES APPEAR TO BE SOME FOUNDATION ISSUES AND THE TWO SHEDS THAT ARE ON SITE, UM, THE OWNER HAS INDICATED THEY'LL BE MOVING THEM OFFSITE.
AND HERE IS OUR SITE VISIT PHOTOS.
IT IS WORTH NOTING SOMETHING, UM, OUTSIDE OF THESE PHOTOS IS THE, UH, FREE LITTLE LIBRARY, UM, AT THE FRONT OF THE PROPERTY.
UM, WHEN SPEAKING WITH OWNER, HE SAYS THEY, THEY WOULD LIKE TO KEEP THAT.
HERE'S THE SIDE IN THE REAR OF THE PROPERTY, THE REAR.
AND HERE ARE THE TWO SHEDS THAT THE OWNER INDICATED WOULD BE, UM, MOVED OFFSITE.
THERE WERE 48 NOTICES MAILED TO PROPERTY WITHIN 500 FEET OF THE PROPERTY.
UH, AND IT WAS NOTICED IN THE BERNIE STAR.
WE RECEIVED SIX WRITTEN NOTICES IN FAVOR OF THE DEMOLITION.
UH, PRIOR TO THIS MEETING, I ALSO RECEIVED ONE IN THE MAIL TODAY FOR THIS ONE AS WELL.
SO A TOTAL OF SEVEN RESPONSES IN FAVOR.
UH, THIS PROPERTY DOES NOT, UH, UH, DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE HISTORIC LANDMARK AND DOES NOT HAVE ANY ARCHITECTURAL, CULTURAL OR EDUCATIONAL VALUE IDENTIFIED BY STAFF.
UH, THE RECOMMENDATION IS THAT HLC SHOULD HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING AND DETERMINE IF IT MEETS THE REQUIREMENTS OF UDC SECTION TWO 11 AND, UH, SHOULD BE CONSIDERED A CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE OR NOT.
UM, I ALSO HAD A CHANCE TO, UM, VISIT THIS SITE AND WE WERE LUCKY THAT MR. NOEL DROVE BY AND LET US IN 'CAUSE WE WERE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW WE CAN GET IN
UM, THIS HOUSE ALSO HAS AN ADDITION AND IT'S GOT P AND BE AND THEN, UM, CONCRETE SLAB AND A PART OF IT.
UM, THERE'S EASILY STRUCTURE, FOUNDATION ISSUES.
YOU CAN SEE WHEN YOU'RE WALKING AROUND, THERE'S BIG CRACKS IN IT.
UM, THERE, THE NEW ADDITION DOES HAVE, YOU KNOW, NEWER LAP SIDING ON IT, BUT YOU CAN DEFINITELY SEE THE, UM, BUT LITTLE SPEED IT'S BEHIND.
I CAN SEE LIKE ON THE BOTTOMS OF IT WHEN YOU'RE WALKING AROUND, BUT THERE'S NOTHING, UM, HISTORICAL THAT NEEDS TO BE KEPT.
UM, A LOT OF 'EM ARE KIND OF ROTTING OUT, SO THEY NEED TO KEEP THOSE EITHER.
UM, THEY DO HAVE A CHAIN LINK FENCE ON TWO SIDES OF THE HOUSE, TWO OR THREE SIDES.
AND WE MENTIONED TO MR. NOEL THAT, YOU KNOW, ACCORDING TO THE NEW, UH, RULES, THAT THAT WILL HAVE TO BE, YOU KNOW, DEMOED AS WELL IN THE NEWER FENCE.
AND HE WAS AWARE OF THAT AND AGREED TO DO THAT AS WELL.
ANYBODY ELSE HAS ANY QUESTIONS? NOPE.
ALRIGHT, I'LL CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING OF THIS, UM, DEMOLITION CREST.
IF WE HAVE ANYBODY TO MAKE A MOTION FOR THIS PROPERTY, I MOVE THAT WE, UH, ACCEPT THE FINDINGS AND APPROVE A DEMOLITION PERMIT REQUEST AT 1 44 GARDEN STREET.
I HAVE A FIRST BY COMMISSIONER GRAVES AND A SECOND BY COMMISSIONER NICHOLS.
FEBRUARY IS OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE.
[00:10:01]
REQUEST FOR 1 44 GARDEN STREET HAS PASSED AS WELL.UM, IS THAT, OH, THAT CLOSES THE REGULAR AGENDA.
[6. COMMENTS FROM COMMISSION/LEGAL COUNSEL/STAFF – No discussion or action may take place.]
COMMENTS FROM COUNSEL OR LEGAL OR STAFF.UM, JUST A QUICK REMINDER THAT NEXT WEEK IS OUR ANNUAL CITY OF BERNIE BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS APPRECIATION OPEN HOUSE.
IT IS WEDNESDAY 1112, UH, FROM SIX TO EIGHT HERE IN CITY HALL.
UM, UH, WE ARE ASKING THAT YOU ARE SVP.
SO HAVE WE SENT WHO DO WE? LAURIE CARROLL.
OR IF YOU WANNA LET ME KNOW, I CAN LET HER KNOW.
FOR TODAY'S VERY LONG MEETING THAT WE HAD ANYBODY LIKE ADUR MR. MOLS MOVES TO ADJOURN THE MEETING.